Tradesy vs Poshmark: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide

by Yvette in Comment — Updated October 23, 2023

Online marketplaces are becoming common, especially for buyers who wish to browse through the internet and make their transactions in the comfort of their homes.

The need has made many sellers look at maximizing their profit by using online marketplaces to make sales.

Therefore, customers must choose the right resale sites for secondhand clothes where their needs can be fully met with no drama.

In this article, we help you understand the factors you should consider in knowing which social marketplace to engage in as we compare Tradesy to Poshmark.

Tradesy vs Poshmark: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide 10

Key Takeaways

  • Tradesy and Poshmark are online marketplaces for buying and selling secondhand items, especially clothing and accessories.
  • Tradesy focuses on women’s luxury and designer brands, while Poshmark has a broader range including men’s, women’s, children’s, and home goods.
  • The resale market is growing rapidly, projected to reach over $400 billion globally by 2031, driven by demand for deals and sustainable shopping.
  • To succeed on these platforms, sellers should know their target audience, take high-quality photos, and price competitively.
  • Tradesy and Poshmark have some differences in their selling process, fees, shipping, payments, and customer service.
  • Choosing between the two depends on your fashion niche, items, and desired selling experience.

An Overview of Tradesy and Poshmark

Tradesy and Poshmark, both well-established online marketplaces, serve as platforms for the buying and selling various products.

Although these two websites share some common features, they exhibit significant differences.


Tradesy, founded in 2009 under the guidance of Tracy DiNunzio, has effectively established itself as a notable player in the luxury resale market.

This online marketplace specializes in facilitating transactions for beauty products, predominantly within the sphere of women’s fashion collections.

It extends a warm welcome to all, permitting the listing of a wide spectrum of luxury women’s items, thereby maintaining a policy of inclusivity and a wide array of offerings.

Tradesy maintains its reputation by subjecting each item to meticulous scrutiny to ensure authenticity, thereby upholding its commitment to providing only genuine luxury items in impeccable condition.

With an extensive user base surpassing 7 million individuals in the United States, actively participating in the exchange of clothing, handbags, footwear, vintage pieces, and accessories, Tradesy has firmly cemented its standing as a reputable and thriving online platform.

In light of the ongoing surge in online shopping trends, it is anticipated that Tradesy will continue to attract a growing number of buyers and sellers, provided the quality of product listings remains consistently high.

Free Brown Louis Vuitton Monogram Leather Handbag Stock Photo

Furthermore, considering the enduring appeal of luxury brands such as Louis Vuitton, Michael Kors, and Christian Louboutin, the platform is poised to attract more discerning women seeking both quality and authenticity in their acquisitions.


Established in 2011 under the leadership of Manish Chandra, Poshmark has evolved into a dynamic online marketplace renowned for fostering social connections among buyers and sellers of previously owned goods.

What sets Poshmark apart from its counterparts, like Tradesy, is its expansive scope.

The platform accommodates a diverse range of products, spanning women’s, men’s, and kids’ clothing, as well as home decor and various other items.

However, these items must meet the platform’s rigorous quality verification standards to ensure their listing on the site.

This inclusive approach positions Poshmark as the ideal destination for those in search of a broad array of products.

By the conclusion of 2020, Poshmark had already amassed a staggering 60 million registered users, with a notable 80% of them being women.

This remarkable user base continues to grow, primarily due to the platform’s sterling reputation for its versatility in item listings, extending far beyond the confines of women’s merchandise.

The Growing Demand for Secondhand Items

In 2022, the global market for secondhand items boasted a substantial market valuation estimated at approximately USD 405.5 billion, with projections indicating a remarkable growth of 13.6% by 2031.

This surge in demand for secondhand goods can be attributed to a multifaceted array of factors.

Foremost, the undeniable allure of securing an excellent deal is crucial in driving the demand for secondhand items.

Shoppers frequenting resale platforms are drawn to the prospect of acquiring items at significantly reduced prices compared to their brand-new counterparts.

This financial incentive, combined with the excitement of discovering unique and one-of-a-kind pieces, holds a strong appeal for both buyers and sellers in this emerging market.

Furthermore, a significant driver of the rise in secondhand shopping is a heightened consumer awareness of their environmental footprint.

In an era where sustainability is crucial, individuals are actively seeking ways to reduce waste. Purchasing pre-owned items contributes to the extension of a product’s life cycle.

This results in a decreased demand for new manufacturing and, consequently, a reduction in the carbon footprint. Both Tradesy and Poshmark are at the forefront of this sustainability movement.

This makes them particularly attractive to eco-conscious consumers.

The future of these marketplaces hinges on their ability to maintain high standards of quality and customer service.

The existing market demand is already promising, and as long as these platforms develop and implement a comprehensive sustainability plan, more buyers and sellers are likely to join their ranks.

Specifically, the global secondhand clothing market is expected to outpace the overall demand for secondhand items, with a projected growth rate of 127% by 2026.

Given their specialization in secondhand clothing, both Poshmark and Tradesy are well-positioned to benefit from this anticipated surge in demand.

What to Sell on Tradesy and Poshmark?

Online businesses in Tradesy and Poshmark offer great opportunities for buyers and sellers. To succeed on these social platforms, it’s vital to know what items work best for each.

Tradesy vs Poshmark: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide 13Understand Your Audience

Tradesy is mainly for women’s fashion. So, if you have quality women’s clothing, jewelry, or wedding gowns in good condition, it’s the right place to sell.

You can also find buyers for women’s beauty accessories here.

Poshmark, in contrast, is versatile. It welcomes designer items of all types, not just fashion.

High-end clothing brands like Louis Vuitton, Tory Burch, and Kate Spade are particularly popular.

Plus, Poshmark is open to men’s and children’s clothing and allows for the sale of items like home goods, wedding items, and home decor.

Showcase Your Merchandise

No matter which platform you choose, one thing is certain: excellent pictures are essential.

High-quality photos grab buyers’ attention and help them assess your item’s condition. Since buyers can’t physically touch the products, clear images are your best tool to attract them and reduce the risk of returns.

In a nutshell, whether you go for Tradesy or Poshmark, align your items with the platform’s core audience and strengths.

Tradesy is a niche for women’s fashion, while Poshmark caters to a broader audience and a variety of product categories. Success hinges on knowing your audience and presenting your items with top-notch visuals.

Start your online selling journey, curate your listings carefully, and watch your items find new homes while contributing to the thriving online resale world.

Key Features of Tradesy and Poshmark

When dealing with either Tradesy or Poshmark, it is critical to understand their key features to give you a smooth transaction experience.

The Selling Process

To make your experience on Tradesy and Poshmark as seamless as possible, it’s vital to understand the fundamental aspects of these platforms.

Here, we’ll walk you through the selling process and pricing on both of these popular online marketplaces.


Selling on Tradesy begins by creating an account through their app. The app is your gateway to making sales.

You should start by taking clear, original photos of the item you wish to sell.

Remember: use your own photos and no downloaded images.Tradesy vs Poshmark: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide 15

Next, provide a truthful description of the item in a simple form. Your asking price is entirely up to you.

Tradesy charges a flat commission of $7.5 for items sold under $50, and for items sold at $50 or more, the commission is 19.8%.

Listing your item is free of charge. It’s recommended to price your items based on the current market rates.

Note that the selling price is what you quote to attract buyers, while the sales price is what you ultimately receive upon a successful transaction.


Sellers on Poshmark also begin by installing the app.

Through the Poshmark app, you’ll upload clear and well-lit photos of the items, ensuring they represent your products accurately. A detailed item description is a must.

Poshmark deducts a flat fee of $2.95 for sales under $15, and for sales over $15, a 20% commission fee applies.

There are no listing fees on Poshmark. You have the freedom to set your own price, but it’s important to set a competitive and good price to attract potential buyers.

To achieve this, consider researching and comparing prices for similar items and brands listed on the platform. Poshmark prides itself on transparency, with no hidden fees or subscriptions.

In conclusion, understanding the selling process and pricing mechanisms on Tradesy and Poshmark is vital for a successful selling experience.

By adhering to the guidelines and recommendations of each platform, you can maximize your chances of selling your items quickly and efficiently.

So, whether you choose Tradesy or Poshmark, your journey as a seller can be a rewarding one with a bit of knowledge and some thoughtful strategy.

Payment Methods and Shipping

Understanding the ins and outs of payment and shipping processes is crucial when navigating Tradesy and Poshmark.

Tradesy vs Poshmark: A Comprehensive Comparison Guide 17Tradesy

Tradesy facilitates transactions using PayPal, debit card, or ACH transfers. To start, you must link your bank account to your Tradesy profile.

After a successful sale, Tradesy goes the extra mile by offering a complimentary shipping kit and pre-paid mailing labels, making shipping a breeze.

However, it’s essential to utilize these provided shipping materials within 10 days of the sale to ensure a smooth transaction process.


On Poshmark, you can choose from payment options like PayPal, credit cards, or bank transfers.

Before listing items for sale, you need to link your preferred payment method to your Poshmark account.

After a sale, Poshmark provides a pre-addressed and pre-paid shipping label designed for packages weighing up to 5 pounds.

It’s then your responsibility to ship the item to the buyer’s address within seven days.

It’s worth noting that any item valued at over $500 undergoes authentication by Poshmark before being delivered to the buyer, enhancing security in high-value transactions.

In addition to these payment and shipping details, it’s crucial to familiarize yourself with any additional fees, return policies, and overall transaction guidelines specific to each platform.

This will ensure a smooth and secure experience when buying or selling on Tradesy or Poshmark.

Customer Service

Understanding the customer service offerings on Tradesy and Poshmark is fundamental for both buyers and sellers.

Let’s explore the support mechanisms and policies on these platforms.


Tradesy takes pride in delivering top-notch customer service. However, it’s important to note that they do not assist via telephone or live chat.

Instead, you can contact their support team through their email address.

Additionally, you can utilize their presence on various social media platforms to seek assistance, with the assurance that their customer service team will respond promptly.

Buyers on Tradesy enjoy the advantage of a money-back guarantee.

This guarantee comes into play when a buyer encounters difficulties acquiring the item precisely as described in the product listing.

Therefore, it’s highly advisable to provide the most accurate and comprehensive item photos to avoid such discrepancies, thus ensuring a smoother transaction.


Poshmark also prides itself on offering robust customer support.

Users of the Poshmark mobile app benefit from 24/7 support accessibility through email.

Additionally, you have the option to contact Poshmark directly, though immediate assistance might not be guaranteed if there’s a high volume of incoming calls.

Poshmark prioritizes buyer satisfaction by rigorously vetting the items listed on its platform to ensure quality. With such thorough scrutiny, Poshmark sales are generally considered final.

However, they do allow returns in the event a buyer receives an item that substantially differs from the original listing.

In such cases, a comprehensive money-back guarantee is applied to safeguard the buyer’s interests.

In summary, both Tradesy and Poshmark place a strong emphasis on customer service.

While their contact methods differ, the overarching goal is to provide support and resolve issues promptly, promoting a secure and reliable environment for buyers and sellers alike.

It is worth noting that each platform has distinct policies regarding returns and money-back guarantees, so it is prudent to familiarize oneself with these before making transactions.

Unpacking the Differences

Tradesy and Poshmark are two popular online fashion marketplaces that offer distinct experiences for sellers and buyers.

To sum it up, Tradesy specializes in high-quality women’s fashion, especially pre-owned items, and places a premium on authenticity.

Meanwhile, Poshmark provides a broader platform, catering to a wide range of products, including designer clothes for men, women, and kids, alongside various non-clothing items.

Which one is right for you?

Well, that depends on your fashion preferences and what you’re looking to achieve.

If you want to sell your gently used designer clothing, Tradesy might be your go-to. But if you’re looking for diversity and enjoy thrifting, Poshmark could be a great option.

Both platforms have their strengths, but the key is to pick the one that suits your style and needs.

Whether you’re buying or selling, make sure to understand the payment, shipping, and return policies.

Ultimately, it’s your fashion adventure, and the choice between Tradesy and Poshmark is about what fits you best.

Happy fashion hunting!

Leave a Comment